Open vs Closed Rhinoplasty: Which one is right for you?

Nov 22 2024

If you're researching Rhinoplasty, one of the first questions you'll encounter is whether an open or closed rhinoplasty is better. The truth is that neither technique is inherently superior. The right approach depends on your anatomy, the changes you want to make and your surgeon's recommendation. In this guide, we'll explain the differences, benefits, recovery times and which procedure may be best suited to your goals.

Feature	Open Rhinoplasty	Closed Rhinoplasty
Incision	Across columella	Inside nostrils
Visible scar	Tiny scar	None
Recovery	Slightly longer	Usually shorter
Swelling	More	Less
Best for	Complex cases	Minor reshaping
Revision surgery	Yes	Rarely
Surgical visibility	Excellent	Limited

What is Open Rhinoplasty?

Open Rhinoplasty is a technique where the surgeon makes a small incision on the columella - the soft tissue between the nostrils. This allows the surgeon to lift the nasal skin, providing greater visibility and access to the underlying nasal structures. Open Rhinoplasty is often recommended for more complex cases where significant reshaping of the nose is required, such as correcting severe asymmetry, performing revisions, or addressing nasal deformities.

Speaking about the procedure, ENT and Facial Plastic Surgeon, Professor Raghavan said:

“The surgery typically takes between two to three hours, depending on the complexity of the changes being made. Once the incisions are made, the surgeon can modify the nasal bone, cartilage, and soft tissues to achieve the desired shape. Afterward, the incisions are carefully sutured, and a splint is placed on the nose to protect it during the healing process. The recovery time for Open Rhinoplasty is generally longer than for Closed Rhinoplasty, with swelling and bruising lasting for several weeks. However, the results are often more precise for patients requiring extensive corrections. While scarring is a potential concern, the incision on the columella is small and typically heals well, becoming almost invisible over time.” - Professor Raghavan

What is Closed Rhinoplasty?

Closed Rhinoplasty, also known as Endonasal Rhinoplasty, is performed entirely within the nostrils, with no external incisions. This technique is less invasive, making it ideal for patients who require minor adjustments to the nose, such as refining the nasal tip or removing a hump. Because the skin is not lifted, the surgeon’s visibility of the nasal structures is more limited compared to Open Rhinoplasty.

Professor Raghavan continued:

“The procedure generally takes less time than Open Rhinoplasty, lasting around one to two hours. The surgeon works through small incisions inside the nostrils, allowing them to make adjustments to the nasal cartilage and bone. Since there are no external cuts, scarring is not a concern, and the recovery time is typically shorter. Patients undergoing Closed Rhinoplasty usually experience less swelling and bruising, and the overall healing process is quicker. However, because the surgeon has less direct visibility, this approach may not be suitable for more complex cases that require extensive reshaping.” - Professor Raghavan

Who is a good candidate?

Open Rhinoplasty may be suitable if you:

You're having revision surgery
You have a crooked nose
Significant tip reshaping is required
Structural grafts are needed
You have severe asymmetry

Closed Rhinoplasty may be suitable if you:

You're seeking subtle cosmetic changes
You have a dorsal hump
You require limited tip refinement
You want no external scar
Your anatomy allows for a less invasive approach

Not sure which Rhinoplasty technique is right for you?

Choosing between open and closed rhinoplasty isn't a decision you need to make alone. During your consultation, your surgeon will assess your anatomy, discuss your goals and recommend the most appropriate surgical approach to achieve a natural-looking result.

Book your free consultation today and receive a personalised treatment plan.

Enquire Now

Pros and cons of Open vs Closed Rhinoplasty

Choosing between Open and Closed Rhinoplasty depends on the specifics of your case and your desired outcomes. Below is a breakdown of the advantages and disadvantages of each approach.

Pros and cons of Open Rhinoplasty

Pros:

Greater visibility for the surgeon, allowing for more precise corrections, especially in complex cases
Easier access to the nasal framework, which is helpful for addressing significant asymmetries, deformities, or performing revisions
More control over reshaping the nose, particularly the nasal tip

Cons:

Longer recovery time due to more extensive surgery
Potential for a small, though typically minimal, scar on the columella
Increased swelling and bruising compared to Closed Rhinoplasty

Pros and cons of Closed Rhinoplasty

Pros:

No visible external scars, as the incisions are made inside the nostrils
Faster recovery time, with less swelling and bruising
Shorter procedure duration compared to Open Rhinoplasty

Cons:

Limited visibility for the surgeon, which can make complex cases more challenging
May not be suitable for significant nasal reshaping or revisions
Less precision in certain areas, particularly when addressing the nasal tip

See how Rhinoplasty has helped our patients

At Pall Mall, our patients have experienced life-changing results from both Open and closed Rhinoplasty procedures. From subtle refinements to major reshaping, our expert surgeons work closely with each patient to ensure their expectations are met.

One notable success story is Gabriella Bardsley, who underwent a Septorhinoplasty procedure. This surgery not only addressed her breathing issues but also improved the overall symmetry and appearance of her nose. Gabriella’s journey exemplifies how Rhinoplasty can achieve both functional and aesthetic goals, offering a comprehensive solution to nasal concerns.

If you’re considering Rhinoplasty and want to know which surgery is right for you, our expert team at Pall Mall is here to help. We offer both Open and Closed Rhinoplasty, as well as Septorhinoplasty for functional corrections. Book a free, no obligation consultation to discuss your cosmetic surgery goals.