Menu Menu

What’s the difference between Motiva and PERLE implants?

The primary difference between PERLE and Motiva implants comes down to how their internal gels manage gravity, structure, and shape retention over time. 

Perle (by GC Aesthetics): These are highly praised by surgeons for offering an excellent balance between safety, softness, and long-term shape retention. They feature an advanced smooth shell and a highly cohesive gel. This means they feel natural but are excellent at holding their form, which is ideal if your surgeon feels you need a bit more structure or upper-pole fullness. They also come with a comprehensive lifetime warranty covering complications like ruptures and capsular contracture. 

Motiva: Known particularly for their Ergonomix line, these use a highly viscoelastic gel designed to flow dynamically with gravity (teardrop when standing, round when lying down). They are extremely soft, but because they have low shape retention by design, they do not provide as much structured upper fullness.

The main differences between Motiva and PERLE Implants

Motiva is an implant manufacturer that produces models including Round, Ergonomix and Ergonomix2. Perle is an implant model that is manufactured by GC Aesthetics - the same way Motiva makes Ergonomix.

FeatureMotiva ImplantsPERLE Implants by GC Aesthetics
GelMotiva Round uses ProgressiveGel PLUS. Ergonomix uses ProgressiveGel ULTIMA, which is softer than the gel in Motiva Round and allows more movement with gravity.Uses Emunomic gel, a highly cohesive, shape-retaining gel.
SoftnessErgonomix designed for softness and adaptabilityDesigned to balance softness with shape retention
Shape and movementRound is designed to provide fullness, including in the upper breast. Ergonomix has a round base but is designed to redistribute its gel with changes in body position, creating a more teardrop-like contour when upright.A round implant designed to provide fullness and projection.
Outer surfaceThe SmoothSilk/SilkSurface models have a surface classified as smooth.Uses a proprietary BioQ surface, described as “smooth opaque”.
Profiles / ProjectionUses names such as Mini, Demi, Full and Corsé, depending on the model and market.The current manufacturer selector lists Low, Moderate, High and Extra High.

Why did my surgeon switch implant brands at my final consultation?

Switching implant brands at the final consultation is common; it usually means your surgeon has taken final measurements and decided a different gel or shell profile will give you a better anatomical result. It likely comes down to how the specific implant will sit within your existing breast tissue.

Surgeons often switch to PERLE if they determine that Motiva's highly flowing gel might lead to bottoming out over time, or if the patient's tissue requires a more supportive implant shell. 

A surgeon explains the difference between Motiva & PERLE for patients

We spoke to Mr Prasad about how he decided whether to use Motiva or PERLE implants for breast augmentation surgery.

"My primary concern is which implant is better suited to the individual patient's anatomy, aesthetic goals and long-term safety.

Both Motiva and Perle by GC Aesthetics offer modern silicone breast implants, but their designs, gel characteristics and clinical evidence differ.

I'd want to understand whether the patient prefers a soft, naturally sloping breast shape, more pronounced upper-pole fullness, or something between the two. For example, Motiva Ergonomix may appeal when softness and movement are important priorities. PERLE may be worth considering when shape retention and projection are particularly important.

However, it’s important not to oversimplify this. Motiva also offers Round implants designed for greater fullness, and PERLE is available in different dimensions and profiles.

Ultimately, a patient's eventual appearance depends on more than implant gel. Existing tissue, implant dimensions, position and healing all influence the outcome. This would potentially influence my choice more than the implant brand.

I'd assess breast base width, skin elasticity, tissue thickness, existing breast volume, nipple position, asymmetry and any breast descent (ptosis).

A patient with very little natural breast tissue may be more susceptible to visible implant edges or rippling. Someone with loose skin after pregnancy or weight loss may need a different approach to achieve an appropriate breast shape.

I'd also consider whether breast augmentation alone is suitable or whether a breast lift should be discussed."

Where I might lean towards Motiva

"If a patient prioritised a softer, mobile breast appearance, I would be particularly interested in Motiva Ergonomix.

Its gel is designed to redistribute with changes in body position, producing a fuller lower contour when standing.

However, I would also consider whether a particularly soft implant might be more susceptible to visible folds or movement in a patient with limited tissue coverage. That is a question to assess, not an established disadvantage in every patient."

Where I might lean towards PERLE

"I would be interested in PERLE when a patient wanted defined projection and shape retention with a cohesive silicone gel.

Its Emunomic gel is designed to maintain cohesiveness while allowing the implant to remain flexible.

I would still want to assess its feel against Motiva in person, using comparable implant volumes and profiles."


Related Articles

What’s the difference between Motiva Preserve breast implants and traditional implants?
Learn how Motiva Preservé implants compare with traditional breast implants in terms of design, natural movement, recovery and long‑term outcomes.
Pall Mall Fallback Image
Pall Mall Fallback Image
How to Choose the Right Breast Implant Size, Shape & Profile

Our guide to choosing the right breast implant covers everything you need to know about implant sizes, shapes, profiles and projection.

Pall Mall Fallback Image
Breast implants: Under the muscle vs over the muscle

Find out more about the placement of breast implants over the muscle vs under the muscle, the benefits of each approach, and how to determine which is right for you.

Pall Mall Fallback Image
Teardrop Vs Round Implants: Which Implants Are Right For Me? | Pall Mall

Considering breast enlargement surgery but don't know if you need round or teardrop breast implants? This guide by Pall Mall explains everything!

Pall Mall Fallback Image
Why More Women are Choosing Small Breast Implants

Terms such as ‘mini boob job’, ‘natural breast augmentation’ and even ‘ballerina breasts’ have helped bring this look into the spotlight.

Pall Mall Fallback Image
Types of Breast Implants: Materials, Profiles & Placement

Learn about the different types of breast implant include the benefits of different materials, profiles and placement.

Pall Mall Fallback Image
The difference between round implants and anatomical implants

Choosing between anatomical and round implants? Our blog breaks down the key differences, helping you make an informed decision for your Breast Enlargement. Understand which option is best for achieving your desired look.

Pall Mall Fallback Image
Everything you need to know about gummy bear implants

Learn all about gummy bear implants, the cohesive silicone gel option for breast augmentation. Explore their benefits, feel, and unique shape retention, and find out if they're the right choice for you.

Pall Mall Fallback Image
Knowing when it’s time for a breast implant replacement

At Pall Mall we offer Breast Implant Removal and Replacement services.

Pall Mall Fallback Image
Breast Implants vs Fat Transfer

Choosing between implants or fat transfer for breast augmentation can be a difficult decision. Here, we compare the differences between each approach.

Pall Mall Fallback Image
Can you breastfeed with breast implants?

Find out everything you need to know about breastfeeding with implants. If you’re thinking about cosmetic surgery, contact Pall Mall for a free, no obligation consultation.

Enquire about Breast Enlargement

A member of our team will be in touch with you to discuss your requirements. 

I agree to receive advice, offers and news by email and SMS in accordance with our privacy policy